"Rock
'Til You Drop - The World Record Edition"
As has
been said before, "Rock 'Til You Drop" was advertised with one of
David Walker's brilliant marketing campaigns, which included Quo setting a new
world record by playing four concerts in four different cities in one day!
Hence the title, and the band were really ready to drop by the time of the
final one. But at least the concert marathon earned them a place in the
Guinness Book of World Records, and helped to return Quo back to the charts (it
helped that the album was much stronger than "Perfect Remedy", of
course). All four gigs were recorded and a VHS containing excerpts from the
live event, as well as a documentary about it, was released. Ideally, this
should have finally been released on DVD for this reissue but it seems that
DVDs are a perennial weak spot of deluxe editions (I'm not ruling out the
possibility of something coming out as a separate DVD or Blu-Ray at some point
though…). Instead, the third disc serves up a pretty good audio representation
of the live event. It's not to be taken for granted that this CD has turned out
as good as it has – I have to thank Luke for insisting upon improving the disc
to a point when it couldn't be improved anymore! The CD now contains every song that was performed by Quo on 21st
September 1991, sequenced in a way that approximates the live setlists in
chronological order while representing all four gigs roughly by an equal
amount. In essence, it's an expanded version of the VHS. Since Quo played two
different setlists on the day (even a band as notorious for playing a static
set like this wouldn't play the exact same set four times in one day!), it's
physically impossible to recreate concert order, but I did try to merge both
setlists together. If you want to program your CD player or arrange a playlist,
this alternate order is at the end of the post.
But
although it's just a "sampler" of the four nights, the CD is an
amazing listening experience. Quo were really in great form (well, mostly), and
the recordings capture that brilliantly. In my humble opinion, this is one of
the highlights of the entire deluxe series! Having two songs that Quo almost
never played live, in pristine audio quality (the mixing is much better than on
the VHS release), is an extra bonus, even if they're "just" covers
(Wilbert Harrison's "Let's Work Together", made famous by Canned
Heat, and "Price of Love" by The Everly Brothers, a song Quo
themselves had already recorded in 1969, and that had already been played live
as a snippet in the Roadhouse Medley on the 1989 tour).
This
leaves us with disc 2, which opens with five non-LP studio recordings (the RTYD
sessions produced a lot of material!). It's worth pointing out that neither of
them appeared on the 2006 remaster of the album, simply because that replicated
the original CD… and that was already full with the six tracks that weren't on
the LP. This says nothing about their quality; any of the four non-album tracks
could've been on the album and replaced the unnecessary re-recording of
"Tommy" or some other album tracks. "Heavy Daze" and
"Better Times" are still semi-rarities, as the "Fakin' the
Blues" CD single was withdrawn and the two tracks only saw a reissue on
the 4CD box set "Rockers Rollin'" from 2001. You may remember the
riff from "Better Times" being played in front of "Rain" in
1987…labelled (partially due to my fault) as ZZ Top's "La Grange" on
the "In the Army Now" 2CD. On the other hand, the riffs are almost
identical, so there. (Apparently this was also already tried out during the
"Perfect Remedy" sessions but the recording remains unreleased, as
does a rehearsal of Fleetwood Mac's "Don't Stop" which eventually
became the title track of the 1996 covers album.)
Then
there is a medley of Quo's four greatest hits (Caroline, Down Down, Whatever
You Want and Rockin' All Over the World) that was released on the "Rock
'Til You Drop" single and used for radio and TV promo purposes. Of course,
there have been "mixes" before like the "Christmas Cake
Mix" or those bizarre Spanish promo versions of "Anniversary
Waltz" but this is an actual new recording by the 1991 line-up. It
wouldn't be the last time that Quo re-recorded those songs: Apart from
"Down Down" (which later got an update as "Prices Are Down"
for the Australian Coles ad), all of them were redone for the 2003 album
"Riffs". "Whatever You Want" also had a 1998 re-recording
and "Rockin' All Over the World" was already remade in 1988 for the
US market and the Sport Aid benefit campaign (as "Running All Over the
World" – see the deluxe edition of "Ain't Complaining").
The
deluxe editions have been a bit undecided when it comes to single edits, and
they've often been left off in favour of more interesting versions (especially
12" mixes in the case of "In the Army Now" and "Ain't
Complaining"). In this case, they should all be there. Except an edit of
"Forty-Five Hundred Times" that appeared on the "Rock 'Til You
Drop" single and later the compilation "The Other Side of Status
Quo" + the 7" versions of "The Anniversary Waltz", which
really could've fit here… as I said in the post on "Perfect Remedy",
they're on several compilations, but still… at the time I was compiling first
drafts, I thought they wouldn't fit on disc 2! There IS a live version of
"Part 1", which may seem superfluous since there's a better sounding
version from the live event. Even though this has the benefit of Rick's voice
sounding much better (he was really done at the end of the gig marathon), you
may wonder why it's here at all. The answer is that it's a holdover from an
early draft that wasn't dropped!
Compiling
these reissues can be like a Catch-22, especially from a fan's/outsider's
perspective… you never know what's going to work and what not, and usually
tracks drop off during the making. Unfortunately it's much easier to drop a
track than to add one, as it means the whole disc has to be "cleared"
again (Universal's internal regulations). On the other hand, it doesn't make
much sense either to supply lists that break the limit of one CD – because if
everything gets OK'd, what do you do with the tracks that don't fit on the
disc?
So that's
the reason why disc 2 is so short. Regretfully, I have to take some
responsibility for that. I wanted to represent the RTYD album as well as
possible: Across various occasions, Quo played no less than eight tracks off
the album. Two were played at the live event and are thankfully represented on
disc 3.
Five
songs were played on the actual tour, although not at every concert. The idea
was to get the best-sounding audience recording of these tracks. Alas, it
couldn't be found. An early test disc still had "Like a Zombie",
"One Man Band", "Fakin' the Blues" and "No
Problems", recorded live in Blackpool. Not in keeping with the latter
title, we were already missing a live version of "Rock 'Til You Drop"
even though I had included one in my draft, but for some reason the test disc
actually contained the short intro tape that Quo played at the event. This is
now on disc 3 but as I said, it's just a shortened studio version that was
played over the PA. Not a live recording. There are good (not audience) live
recordings of the track as well as "One Man Band". It's hard even for
me now to reconstruct what exactly went wrong.
The
Blackpool tapes were technically poor quality, but not any less listenable than
the recordings appended to the deluxe editions of "Hello!" or
"Quo" (both of which were before my involvement with the series), and
they showed a band on fire and an absolutely hilarious Rossi announcement.
Sadly, they were all dropped, and no replacement versions were sought, even
though I did have a note in my draft pointing out that there are multiple
good-sounding live versions of "One Man Band"… just not from the 1991
tour. Unusually for Quo, the song stayed in the setlist for a relatively long
time (at least until 1995). With hindsight, I should've included that song in
my draft for the "Thirsty Work" deluxe too, just in case. You live
and learn… or maybe not, since the same
issue had already arisen on "In the Army Now". Sigh.
You may
have been doing your maths and notice that I was speaking of eight songs played
live. Well, the other elusive one is "Can't Give You More", a song
that originally comes from the 1977 album "Rockin' All Over the
World" (a pretty stunning extended version appeared in the guise of John
Eden's remix – if you don't have the RAOTW deluxe yet, get it immediately!!)
and was one of a handful of re-recordings done by Quo for the "Rock 'Til
You Drop" album. This one actually had a reason for its existence, as it
was supposed to be used in an advertising campaign for a French mineral water
("Eau Eau Eau" - you get it? Oh well...), but even though this didn't
happen, the song did see a single release and was a modest hit. (In 1985, Bob
Young had already recorded his country-influenced version, which also started
with the "oh oh oh oh" chorus, but that's another topic.) In order to
promote the single, Quo appeared at some TV stations in France and actually performed
the song (plus some other such as "Whatever You Want") live,
including a guitar solo!
I thought
(and still think) that this would be a worthwhile addition to the album, and a
good way to wrap up disc 2. It was included on the aforementioned test disc,
but had some dropouts and wasn't amazing sonically. By the time I had managed
to track down a better sounding recording, it was dropped. Le sigh c'est moi.
Of
course, a point could be made that disc 1 offers more value than any other
"first discs" in the series so far. Indeed, an early version of the
tracklisting had only the ten original LP tracks on disc 1! I thought, at the
time, that that would be a right ol' waste of space, especially with all the
stuff I wanted to include on disc 2… if only I'd known! But I didn't see the
point in making an album that had always been a long CD into a replica of the
vinyl, just for the sake of vinyl revivalism. The epic re-recording of
"Forty-Five Hundred Times" (twelve minutes of madness!) does feel
like a proper ending of the album, having it in the middle of disc 2 would've
defeated the point. Interestingly enough though: If you count the CD bonus
tracks (11-16) and the four non-album b-sides, you end up with 50 minutes of
material – more than the "main album"! Quo were productive in 1991,
no doubt. Even without the covers and remakes, it's still about an hour of new
music. (The Thirsty Work sessions were
similarly productive, giving us about 86 minutes of music!) The new liner notes
reveal that the band actually toyed with the idea of recording two albums from
the 1991 sessions, á la "Just Supposin'"/"Never Too Late" a
decade earlier.
Anyway –
whichever way you spin it, the 3-CD release of "Rock 'Til You Drop"
is still a very worthwhile release highlighting a great "return to
form" album for Quo. I just think disc 2 could've been better.
When I
first came across a Quo forum, a deluxe edition of Rock 'Til You Drop was one
of the hot topics. When I later got in touch with
"master-of-all-reissues" Steve Hammonds and started to send him some
of my dream deluxe edition lists, I really wanted the series to continue beyond
the classic years, mainly in order to reach RTYD.
To
finally have it in my hands is a surreal feeling. To admit that it isn't as
good as it could have been, though, and even partially due to my fault, is very
painful for me.
With
hindsight, I'd have suggested a much better disc 2:
- Dead in the Water 3:50
- Mysteries from the Ball 3:48
- Heavy Daze 4:12
- Better Times 3:26
- (Brit Awards) Medley 3:56
- The Anniversary Waltz Part 1 (7" Version) 5:32
- The Anniversary Waltz Part 2 (7" Version) 5:29
- Can't Give You More (Single Edit) 3:59
- Fakin' the Blues (Single Edit) 3:16
- Forty-Five Hundred Times (B-Side Edit) 6:24
- Can't Give You More (Promo Edit) 3:05
- Don't Stop (1991 version) [supposedly tried out during the RTYD sessions, but it's not clear whether a recording of this exists]
- Like a Zombie (Live 1991) [Blackpool or Glasgow…probably wouldn't get through either way, sadly; there are only four audience recordings of this great song]
- One Man Band (Live at Royal Albert Hall 1994, Skanderborg or Brasov 1995)
- Fakin' the Blues (Live 1991/1992) [Wembley, Peterborough, Gothenburg, Borlänge?]
- No Problems (Live 1991/1992) [Wembley, Peterborough, Gothenburg, Borlänge?]
- Rock 'Til You Drop (Live in Madrid 1992, or Royal Albert Hall 1994)
- Can't Give You More (Live at Paris TV 1992) 4:37 [if a better sounding source could be found]
"Anniversary
Waltz" is a bit of a Janus-headed single. The 7" edit was released on
the 2006 remaster of "Perfect Remedy" but the single also paved the
way for "Rock 'Til You Drop", not just because it included a short snippet
of Wilbert Harrison's "Let's Work Together" as well as the (already
recorded by Quo) Dion track "The Wanderer". The whole sound and
production are more in line with RTYD.
The
problem remains... there are no professional recordings of "One Man
Band" (or the other RTYD tracks) that fit the album's timeframe. There ARE
bootlegs that have better rating in the bootleg indices than the Blackpool
tracks that were on first test discs, though –
Wembley (3 nights in December 1991), Petersborough, Borlänge (January
1992), Dornbirn (March 1992), Hannover (April 1992), Östervåla (July 1992),
Glasgow, Wembley (December 1992), Telford (November 1993), Brighton (December
1993)... not that I've heard all of them! Rock 'Til You Drop was also played at
most of these gigs, and as mentioned above exists as a FM broadcast from
Madrid.
To
finish, here's the "smashed together" setlist that you may want to
try out for an alternate listening experience of disc 3:
5 - Rock
'til You Drop (Intro) [2nd gig, Glasgow]
6 - Down
Down [2nd gig, Glasgow]
1 - Paper
Plane [1st gig, Sheffield]
7 - Roll
Over Lay Down [2nd gig, Glasgow]
9 -
Little Lady [3rd gig, Birmingham]
2 - Price
of Love [1st gig, Sheffield]
8 - Let's
Work Together [2nd gig, Glasgow]
12 -
Burning Bridges [4th gig, Wembley]
3 -
Mystery Medley [1st gig, Sheffield]
4 - Rain
[1st gig, Sheffield]
10 -
Whatever You Want [3rd gig, Birmingham]
11- In
the Army Now [3rd gig, Birmingham]
13 -
Rockin' All Over the World [4th gig, Wembley]
14 - The
Anniversary Waltz [4th gig, Wembley]
15 - Rock
'n' Roll Music/Sweet Soul Music/Bye Bye Johnny [4th gig, Wembley]
One
"error" that also originated with me is the titling of "Encore
Medley". This was always only meant as an internal reference and didn't
take up as much space in a spreadsheet as "Rock and Roll Music / Sweet
Soul Music / Bye Bye Johnny" would've taken. It wasn't totally wrong, as
usually this combination of tracks was the last encore at a Quo gig (and,
without "Sweet Soul Music", stayed in the set until very recently)...
only not during this event, where it ended the set. And of course they didn't
do any encores!
We end with Luke's preview videos:
Keine Kommentare:
Kommentar veröffentlichen